Q235B vs Q345B vs Q345D, what’s the difference?

Here’s a detailed comparison of Q235B, Q345B, and Q345D steels, focusing on their properties, applications, and key differences:

 

 

 

1. Overview

 

2. Mechanical Properties

 

3. Chemical Composition

 

4. Key Differences

Q235B vs. Q345B

Strength: Q345B has ~50% higher yield strength than Q235B (345 MPa vs. 235 MPa).

Applications: Q235B: Non-critical structures (e.g., fences, brackets).

Q345B: Load-bearing structures (bridges, cranes, buildings).

Cost: Q235B is cheaper but weaker; Q345B offers better strength-to-cost ratio for heavy-duty use.

Q345B vs. Q345D

Impact Toughness: Q345B: Tested at 20°C (≥34 J).

Q345D: Tested at -20°C (≥34 J), making it suitable for cold climates.

Purity: Q345D has stricter limits on P and S (better weldability and ductility).

Applications: Q345B: General structural use in mild environments.

Q345D: Cold-region infrastructure (Arctic pipelines, offshore platforms).

 

5. Applications

 

6. Fabrication Considerations

Welding: Q235B: Easy to weld with standard methods (no preheating required).

Q345B/Q345D: Require preheating (100–150°C) and low-hydrogen electrodes to avoid cracking.

Formability: Q235B is more ductile; Q345B/D need careful bending due to higher strength.

Corrosion: None are corrosion-resistant; coatings (e.g., galvanizing) are essential for harsh environments.

 

7. Standards and Equivalents